The Intentional Procreator vs. Casual Inseminator

Things I've learned.

OR

I haven't learned anything, But these are
things that I've Come to Ponder.



The Surrogacy Laws in California are all based on Case law as opposed to 
laws written by the legislature.


That means that people have sued somebody in court and the judges ruling on 
that case would be used to decide future cases "like that one."


The most significant case in California regarding Surrogacy is the Buzzanca case, 
which happened in 1998. 


In that case, a married couple used donor egg and donor sperm, and a surrogate. 


A month before the birth of the child, the couple divorced, and when the child was turned over to the intended mother, she asked for child support. 


The intended father refused to pay, claiming that he was not the parent. 


Because we didn't have any law at the time, the trial court found that he was not the father, and the intended mother wasn't the mother, because they weren't genetically the parents. 


When the case was appealed, the appellate court acted very swiftly in correcting the trial court, and came up with the rule of the case, and that is that both intended parents were the legal parents of the child. 


The rule in the case was that if parents through a surrogacy contract intend to create a child, and they set in motion a medical procedure which results in the creation of the child, they are the parents, whether they're genetically related or not. 


The interesting quote in the case was, paraphrasing, 


"The intentional procreator is as responsible as the casual inseminator."


And that is how California Surrogacy laws protecting the "Intended Parents" was born.

Comments

Cyn said…
Huh! Love the intro!
October 30, 2010 at 9:46 AM
IVF Land on Surrogacy World said…
Basically, the law sums up to say that a parent that "Intentional" means to become a parent through IVF and Surrogacy is just as much a legal parent as someone that happens ti be a "Casual Inseminator" such as a one night stand.

This meant that parentage could be determined just by the intent of the parties.
October 30, 2010 at 11:42 PM
Cyn said…
Sorry, my huh wasn't clear. I understand what you were saying. It's interesting that our laws in regards to surrogacy are based on that case, I really had no idea.
October 31, 2010 at 9:08 AM
IVF Land on Surrogacy World said…
There is another big case where the Surrogate wanted to keep the baby because the parent's were not treating HER right during the pregnancy.

The court ruled that the Surrogate was the Birth Mother, the Intended Parent was the Genetic Mother. This gave them equal rights to claims as the mother.

The Tie-breaker was the INTENT of the contact and who they agreed was going to be the mother before transfer.
November 8, 2010 at 10:22 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I See Pregnant Women....And Small Children

Since we are talking about other blogs that inspire a post I will point to Xbox4NappyRash: The seventh sense in which he talks about developing a 7th sense - the ability to see infertile people. I got it a little different - I See Pregnant Women....And Small Children. When I was a small child I would go to the beach and see other small children. Others like me to play with in the sand. Then as I got a little bit older I became interested in the basketball court near the beach and was aware of the other basketball players that where on the court. As a got still older, I became aware of the girls in the bikini's at the beach. All of a sudden they were everywhere - and they were the only ones on the beach. Recently, when I go to the beach I see Pregnant Women....And Small Children all over the place. I constantly have to work hard not to step on them as they play in the surf. These young families are new to the beach. They have never been there before now - yet now they are all of the
Read more

Mr. Inspiring

Check it out! Someone thinks that I am inspiring. Really! go to Our Surrogacy Adventure and read how I inspired her post, but notice that I didn't inspire her enough to be added to her blogroll. This is what I am talking about when I say that we meet new friends on our adventure. This would be a prime example. Take note, if you women that are reading my blog want me to post more that is how you get it done - stroke my ego. Men really are that simple. Now here is my response to the heart of her post - why do I blog? This is the point when almost everyone says "so that friends and family can follow our journey". That's not me. I want my family to be able to enjoy the excitement of our new addition and don't want to take them on the rollercoaster ride with us. They are really supportive, but we have to go through enough already without taking our entourage with us every step of the way. We just want to give them the happy days. So then, who is the audience that I wa
Read more

Mr. Excited

Mr. Excited has arrived on the scene. He is the happy go lucky guy that is ready to take on any new adventure. He doesn't see how anything can go wrong and wants to "damn the torpedoes, go full speed ahead." We know the odds now, (way to well) so how do we use them to our advantage? Let's double our odds by doubling our surrogates. The math seems really simple. Sure having all of the people involved can make things complicated, but Mr. Excited just wants to hear about the results - not the complications. We have One goal. One Mission. AND One Obsession . So with our eyes firmly on the prize we are moving forward with a new Adventure of a Lifetime . We have built a new team to join us and are ready and excited about moving forward again. We have named our surrogates Ajysyt and Isis. To give them their privacy on the web. Also, it just seemed like a lot of fun to keep people guessing. Our goal is to share this story with everyone. To accomplish this we have started
Read more